



Recruiting News Network
Recruiting
News
OperationsThe Recruiting Worx PodcastMoney + InvestmentsCareer AdviceWorld
Tech
DEI
People
People on the Move
The Leaders
The Makers
People
People on the Move
The Leaders
The Makers
Brand +
Marketing
Events
Labor +
Economics
SUBSCRIBE





Talent

Is your employer guilty of talent hoarding?

April 24, 2024

Talent

Is your employer guilty of talent hoarding?

April 24, 2024

Photo by Lucia Sorrentino on Unsplash

Talent hoarding describes a situation where a manager holds onto a high-performing employee in a way that restricts their professional development or the company’s ability to utilize their skills effectively. It might seem positive on the surface, but it can backfire for both the employee and the employer.

Here’s a breakdown of the concept:

  • Managers holding onto employees: This can be due to a fear of losing a valuable asset on their team, or simply not wanting to deal with the hassle of recruiting and training someone new.
  • Detrimental to employee growth: By keeping the employee in the same role, the manager might be stifling their chances to learn new skills, take on more responsibility, or advance in their career.
  • Detrimental to company growth: The company misses out on the opportunity to leverage the employee’s talent in other areas where it might be more beneficial. It can also lead to knowledge silos and hinder internal mobility within the organization.

New research released from MIT Sloan Management Review shows that talent hoarding — manager behaviors that prevent subordinates from pursuing jobs elsewhere within a company — is bad for organizations, employees, and managers themselves. “Why You Should Let Your Favorite Employee Move to Another Team” shares data-backed evidence that letting their best employees go is often in managers’ own best interests.

Year after year, employees report that the No. 1 reason they leave an organization is the lack of opportunities for career advancement. JR Keller, an associate professor of human resource studies in the School of Industrial and Labor Relations at Cornell University, argues that “hoarding talent is a real short-term mindset with very long-term negative consequences for all — managers, employees, and organizations.”

Managers can control this and should keep the following points in mind when considering their own leadership performance:

  • Managers must be willing to give up talent if they wish to become talent magnets. Earning a reputation as a manager no one wants to work for will not only minimize a draw on talent but also limit a manager’s own ability to advance.
  • Letting people move on is good for organizations and managers. Employees know which managers are better to work for, and they want to work for managers who get their people promoted.
  • Employees know which managers give out titles without meaningful responsibility changes. While managers may have real incentives to hold on to high performers, their reputations as talent blockers will cost them and their organizations in the long run.
  • Hoarding is costly to organizations. The best way to get employees to stay is to show them that they can advance their careers within the organizations.

‍

Read full article here

It might seem positive on the surface, but it can backfire for both the employee and the employer.

What we're reading

‘We’re all fighting the giant’: Gig workers around the world are finally organizing

by
Peter Guest
-
rest of world

Gig workers are connecting across borders to challenge platforms’ power and policies

Got Zoom fatigue? Out-of-sync brainwaves could be another reason videoconferencing is such a drag

by
Dr. Julie Boland
-
The Conversation

I was curious about why conversation felt more laborious and awkward over Zoom and other video-conferencing software.

How to Purchase an Applicant Tracking System

by
Dave Zielinski
-
SHRM

Experts say the first step in seeking a new ATS should be to evaluate your existing recruiting processes.

View All Articles

Events

Detecting AI in Hiring: Ensuring Fair Candidate Assessment

Online
-
to
August 20, 2025

Marketing Brew Summit

New York, NY
-
to
September 10, 2025

Indeed FutureWorks

New Orleans, LA
-
September 10, 2025
to
September 11, 2025
View All Events
Related Articles

Talent acquisition in the modern world: what does good look like

Melanie Forbes

August 13, 2025

3 Subtle Ways To Keep Prospects In Your Talent Pipeline Engaged

Dr John Sullivan

August 13, 2025

© 2024 recruiting news network.
all rights reserved.



Categories
Technology
Money
People
TA Ops
Events
Editorial
World
Career Advice
Resources
Diversity & Inclusion
TA Tech Marketplace
Information
AboutContactMedia KitPrivacy Policy
Subscribe to newsletter
